Government faces backlash over location-tracking proposal
The Indian government is pushing a telecom industry proposal that will compel smartphone companies to allow satellite location tracking that will be activated 24x7 for surveillance.
Tech giants Samsung, Google, and Apple have opposed this move due to privacy concerns. Privacy debates have stirred in India after the government was forced to repeal an order that mandated smartphone companies to pre-install a state run cyber safety application on all devices. Activists and opposition raised concerns about possible spying.
About the proposal
Recently, the government had been concerned that agencies didn't get accurate locations when legal requests were sent to telecom companies during investigations. Currently, the firm only uses cellular tower data that provides estimated area location, this can be sometimes inaccurate.
The Cellular Operators Association of India (COAI) representing Bharti Airtel and Reliance Jio suggested accurate user locations be provided if the government mandates smartphone firms to turn on A-GPS technology which uses cellular data and satellite signals.
Strong opposition from tech giants
If this is implemented, location services will be activated in smartphones with no disable option. Samsung, Google, and Apple strongly oppose this proposal. A proposal to track user location is not present anywhere else in the world, according to lobbying group India Cellular & Electronics Association (ICEA), representing Google and Apple.
Reuters reached out to the India's IT and home ministries for clarity on the telecom industry's proposal but have received no replies. According to digital forensics expert Junade Ali, the "proposal would see phones operate as a dedicated surveillance device."
According to technology experts, utilizing A-GPS technology, which is normally only activated when specific apps are operating or emergency calls are being made, might give authorities location data accurate enough to follow a person to within a meter.
Telecom vs government
Globally, governments are constantly looking for new ways to improve in tracking the movements or data of mobile users. All Russian mobile phones are mandated to have a state-sponsored communications app installed. With 735 million smartphones as of mid-2025, India is the second-largest mobile market in the world.
According to Counterpoint Research, more than 95% of these gadgets are running Google's Android operating system, while the remaining phones are running Apple's iOS.
Apple and Google cautioned that their user base will include members of the armed forces, judges, business executives, and journalists, and that the proposed location tracking would jeopardize their security because they store sensitive data.
According to the telecom industry, even the outdated method of location tracking is becoming troublesome because smartphone manufacturers notify users via pop-up messages that their "carrier is trying to access your location."